Zazzle removes Geek t-shirt products due to unreasonable Pi Trademark.

Posted by Alex Corona

Jun 2, 2014 9:31:07 AM

The United States Patent and Trademark Office have added to their list of questionable trademarks and patents with the trademarking of the symbol Pi in the form of π. (pi with a period)

The Brooklyn based artist Paul Ingrisano, owner of “Pi Productions Corp" trademarked the symbol with a period to apparently differentiate between his t shirt products and the well know mathematical symbol.

Now usually trademark law states that one letter differences or minute changes don't meet the requirements of being unique yet, what do you know, the USPTO allowed it and the mark was filed in January this year.

Alone this wouldn't spark too much controversy but Mr Ingrisano applied for legal counsel shortly after and began sending cease and desist letters out to Zazzle, the custom print  T-shirt and gift store ordering them to remove Pi symbol related products from the site — even those that didn't contain the "period". 

Zazzle promptly removed any design containing the Pi symbol to the disgruntle of many of their sellers. After a hailstorm of complaints and emails from customers over the illegitimacy and frankly ridiculousness of the claim Zazzle have been putting Pi products back on the site.

Trademark law and the Pi symbol.

As you may well know from your school days Pi is the Greek letter π and has been around since ancient Greece. Under trademark law you can't trademark a mathematical symbol and especially one that has been used in designs before. Which brings us to the next point

The mark is far too generic for t shirt designs and has been for decades, from geeky Pi-related t-shirts to clothing by fraternities and sororities.

Adding the period should not have permitted Ingrisano the trademark, yet somehow it slipped through.

Lastly Mr Ingrisano has been trying to enforce his mark on T-shirt designs on Zazzle indiscriminately . As a logo the trademark of the π. symbol is not for the mathematical symbol, which means products which make use of the mathematical symbol are not in breach of Mr Ingrisanos trademark rights and can only have a loose claim on conceptual similarities.

But with any company that has an understanding of trademark law and is being affected by Mr Ingrisanos claim there is going to be some anger and confusion. 

Regards

Alex

Subscribe to Email Updates

Free eBooks